As parents, we often encounter situations where our children resist spending time with us or the other parent. This resistance can be puzzling and frustrating, leaving us wondering why our child is behaving this way and how we can address the issue. The reasons behind a child’s resistance to access can be complex, stemming from a variety of factors, both within the child and the family dynamics. Understanding the root causes and employing effective strategies can help us navigate these challenging situations and ensure our child’s well-being.
The Counterwill Instinct: The Root of Resistance
One of the key reasons children resist their parents’ directions and requests is a natural human instinct called “counterwill.” This instinct, first coined by a student of Freud named Otto Rank, is activated when a child feels coerced or controlled by others. It’s the reason why they might slow down when told to speed up or do the opposite of what they’re told. The more a parent tries to assert their authority, the more the child may resist.
However, this counterwill instinct serves an important function. Children are only supposed to follow and obey the people they are attached to, such as their parents. This helps them discern when a stranger tries to tell them what to do, but it also explains why they might routinely resist their parents’ directions.
Attachment and the Counterwill Instinct
Young children, in particular, often resist their parents’ instructions due to a lack of attachment in the moment. Children can only focus on one thing at a time, and if they are engrossed in something else, their parent’s requests may fall on deaf ears. The key to overcoming this resistance is to engage the child’s attachment instincts before giving them instructions.
For older children, the counterwill instinct helps them develop a separate sense of self, with their own ideas, preferences, and desires. As they grow, it’s natural for their agendas to differ from their parents’, leading to more frequent disagreements. The challenge for parents is to preserve the child’s dignity and their own while navigating these conflicts.
Strategies for Dealing with Resistance and Opposition
Fortunately, there are several effective strategies parents can employ to steer through these battles and avoid letting the relationship suffer:
1. Don’t Parent Cold – Collect the Attachment Instincts First
Before giving a child instructions, it’s crucial to engage with them in a friendly, receptive way. This helps the child feel connected and more willing to follow directions, as the attachment instinct overrides the counterwill instinct.
2. Expect Resistance and Make Room for It
When the counterwill instinct has been provoked, acknowledge the child’s resistance and proceed forward without increasing coercion. You can say something like, “I know you don’t like me telling you to make your bed, but it still needs to be done.”
3. Cultivate Routines and Structure for the Child to Attach To
Establishing a daily structure and predictable routines can help a child feel less coerced and controlled, as they can attach to the routine itself.
4. Put Them in Charge Wherever Appropriate
Allowing children to make age-appropriate decisions, such as choosing their clothes or toys, can help avoid power struggles and satisfy their desire for self-expression.
5. Repair Fallout from Counterwill Battles
If you’ve had conflicts with your child due to the counterwill instinct, a simple repair and acknowledgment can help mend the relationship and convey that it remains intact.
Understanding the Reasons Behind Resistance
While the counterwill instinct is a common factor, there can be other reasons why a child may resist access or visitation with a parent. It’s essential to explore the underlying causes to address the issue effectively.
Justified Rejection
If a parent has a history of abuse, neglect, or poor parenting, the child’s resistance to access may be justified. In these cases, the child’s complaints tend to be clear and specific, with documented evidence of the problematic behavior.
Unjustified Rejection
Sometimes, a child’s resistance is influenced by one parent’s negative opinions or emotions towards the other parent. In these scenarios, the child’s complaints are often vague and lack concrete examples.
A Poor Fit Between Parent and Child
If the personalities, interests, or parenting styles of the two parents are significantly different, the child may find it easier to connect with one parent over the other, leading to resistance.
The Chameleon Child
Some children may resist access or visitation with both parents, as they have learned that aligning with one parent’s negative views can earn them favor and attention.
Addressing Resistance: Legal Considerations and Practical Strategies
When a child refuses visitation or access to the other parent, it can have legal consequences. It’s crucial to understand your responsibilities as a co-parent and the potential legal implications of the situation.
Involving Legal and Mental Health Professionals
If the resistance is justified due to safety concerns, it’s essential to consult with your attorney and mental health professionals to explore options for modifying the parenting plan or implementing appropriate safeguards.
Encouraging Cooperation and Understanding
Even when the resistance is not justified, it’s important to validate your child’s feelings, empathize with the challenges of the situation, and work to make the transitions as smooth as possible. Maintaining a positive and confident attitude can help your child feel more secure and willing to cooperate.
Fostering Connections and Rebuilding Relationships
If your child is resisting access to you, it’s an opportunity to step up and strengthen your relationship. Focus on being a good listener, making adjustments to accommodate your child’s needs, and seeking the help of a child therapist to rebuild the connection.
Akilah Harris Helps Clients With All Aspects of Divorce Including Custody
When you have made the decision to pursue divorce, it is important to remember that you have a number of different options. There are more options than just one avenue of divorce – we can explain the different methods which are available to you and explore the one which is most suited to your needs.
> Learn More
Navigating a child’s resistance to access or visitation can be a complex and emotionally charged situation. By understanding the underlying causes, such as the counterwill instinct and other family dynamics, and employing effective strategies, parents can work to preserve the child’s well-being and maintain healthy relationships with both parents. With patience, empathy, and a commitment to prioritizing the child’s best interests, families can overcome these challenges and find a path forward that supports the child’s development and emotional needs.
Contact(954-451-0050) Akilah Harris, PLLC for a Consultation!
—
